Don’t Talk About Your Feelings (At Least Not All the Time)

Many relationship experts assume that emotional disconnection sits at the heart of relationship distress. Their remedy is to turn towards each other, to reach for your partner when you’re upset or disappointed and share what’s on your mind.

It’s a modern article of faith that we should talk about our feelings and share our vulnerability. If you’re angry, say so. If you’re anxious, let your partner know. Many couples come to therapy convinced that more openness and more emotional honesty is the answer.

But what if that’s wrong and we’ve got it backwards?

Not every feeling needs an audience

Previous generations often expected relatively little emotionally from marriage. Well into the twentieth century, many marriages were emotionally restrained. Men, in particular, were expected to be guarded and emotionally reserved. Openness about feelings was uncommon and often discouraged.

A correction was overdue.

But we’ve swung too far. Now, every anxiety gets outsourced; every frustration becomes a relationship conversation. Every uncomfortable feeling is treated as something that should immediately be shared and pored over together.

If the old mistake was emotional repression, the new mistake is emotional incontinence. We have become uncomfortable with the idea that adults should be able to manage a decent chunk of their emotional lives on their own.

Self-regulation should not be confused with emotional avoidance. Some feelings need reflection. Some dissipate with time. Some are the product of hunger, exhaustion, stress or simply a bad day. Some benefit from a night’s sleep. And some can be handled on your own.

One of the most valuable relationship skills is knowing when to lean on your partner, and when not to, even if that flies in the face of the dominant messages of modern relationship advice.

The real task of a relationship: Growing up together

The central task of an intimate relationship isn't emotional fusion; it’s learning to remain connected while staying psychologically separate. It means being able to love another person without losing yourself, and being close without merging. Healthy relationships require judgement and independence, as well as openness.

In practice, that means tolerating disappointment without immediately demanding reassurance. It means accepting that someone can love you while disagreeing with you or failing to understand exactly how you feel.

Many couples expect much more. They assume a good partner should always be emotionally available, endlessly patient and ready to help them process and make sense of whatever they’re feeling, whenever they are feeling it.

article continues after advertisement

But that’s an impossible job and no one can sustain it.

Your partner will sometimes be tired, distracted or preoccupied with problems of their own. They will misunderstand. They will see the world differently and they won’t always know the right thing to say. That doesn’t mean they’re emotionally unavailable; it means they’re human. And, of course, sometimes you’ll be having an unnecessarily over-the-top emotional reaction that they don’t share.

Relationships help us grow precisely because they ask us to tolerate these moments rather than eliminate them. To modern ears, that can sound cold. It isn’t. But it’s adulting — taking responsibility for your own emotional life while remaining open to love and support from another person.

The risks of emotional overdependence

The idea that you should be able to bring all of your emotional needs to your partner is so ingrained that often, if a partner struggles with that, they are cast as the problem: emotionally unavailable, avoidant or incapable of intimacy.

But being on standby to manage someone else’s emotional dependence is rarely attractive. It is difficult to sustain sexual desire for someone you feel responsible for propping up. Esther Perel has argued for years that desire requires separateness. We are attracted to people we experience as independent and capable, not people we have to look after. Love often grows through caregiving; desire does not.

The pandemic taught this lesson. Many couples had assumed their problem was that they didn’t spend enough time together or talk enough. Then COVID arrived and it turned out that wasn't the problem at all. Modern couples increasingly expect one relationship to provide what previous generations found across friends, family, neighbours, colleagues and religious communities.

Few relationships can survive that burden and the outcome is often disappointment and resentment: one partner feels overwhelmed, the other feels neglected, and both wonder where the attraction went.

The middle ground: What actually works

Good relationships depend on honesty, openness and turning towards one another. But they also depend on restraint.

article continues after advertisement

Before you share something difficult, ask yourself a few questions:

• Is this something I need to say, or just something I’m feeling right now?
• Is this the right moment?
• Am I looking for understanding, or am I asking my partner to make this feeling disappear?
• Can I tolerate them seeing things differently?
• Can I calm myself first?

Timing matters. If your partner has an important meeting tomorrow morning, put a pin in it. “Can we talk tomorrow, when I can give it my full attention?” is a reasonable request sometimes. And when you do talk, aim for acknowledgment not agreement. You don’t need your partner to tell you everything will be fine. Understanding how you feel is enough.

Recognise that people regulate themselves differently. Some people want to talk. Others would prefer to go for a run. Sometimes the healthiest response isn’t another conversation. Cook dinner together. Go for a walk. Many emotions settle without analysis.

And if you’re naturally the more emotionally expressive partner, pay attention to how often you’re looking for reassurance, validation or agreement. It feels comforting in the short term but can gradually become a dependency. And If your partner has never been emotionally expressive, don’t expect miracles. People can grow, but they rarely become someone entirely different. Loving someone means accepting their strengths and limitations.

A healthy emotional life is spread across several relationships, not concentrated in one. The goal of a relationship isn’t to narrate your inner life in real time. It’s about knowing which feelings need sharing, which need reflection and which simply need time. That’s emotional maturity.

‍